Ohr
Somayach /
|
||||||||
Solution Contents |
Sherlox Holmes And The Jewelry MysteryWatstein stood at the door of the mahogany study. "Someone's out here to see you, Mr. Holmes. He says you weren't expecting him but that it's an emergency." "You mean the wealthy-looking, neatly-dressed man sitting comfortably in the burgundy chair with his right leg crossed over his left and his hands clasped together?" asked world famous detextive Sherlox Holmes. "Why, how in heaven did you know all that?" "Simple. On the wall behind you I see a reflection whose shape and position indicate beyond a doubt that it originates from a highly polished shoe resting just at the left knee of someone sitting in the burgundy chair. Above that and to the right is the reflection of a diamond-studded ring, whose position indicates hands clasped about the middle. There's so much information one can gather from a simple little ring." "Speaking of rings," said Watstein, "can you help me understand this verse: The man took a gold ring weighing a beka, and two bracelets for her hand, their weight being ten sela. (Bereishis 24:22)" "Is it surprising that Eliezer would give Rivka presents, hoping to win her as Yitzchak's bride?" said Sherlox. "Not at all," said Watstein. "But why does Rashi need to comment? Rashi says that by the beka weight, Eliezer hinted to the beka that future Jews would donate to the Temple. The two bracelets hinted to the Two Tablets, and the weight of ten sela hinted to the ten commandments contained therein." "Isn't that poetic!" said Sherlox. "The very inception of the Jewish people, Yitzchak's marriage to Rivka, is suffused with hidden metaphors symbolizing their ultimate goal: Receiving the Two Tablets containing the ten commandments!" "But Rashi wasn't writing poetry! Rashi himself says: I come only to explain the plain meaning of the text, or to offer aggadic explanations which answer difficulties in the text. (Bereishis 3:8) So, I ask you, Mr. Homes: What's bothering Rashi?" "There's so much information one can gather from a simple little ring," said Sherlox. |
|---|
The first section of this week's Parsha describing the purchase of Sara's burial site contains seven references to "burying a dead person." These refer prophetically to the seven people to be buried there - Avraham & Sara, Yitzchak & Rivka, Yaakov & Leah - and the wicked Esav, whose head is buried there.
|
|
All references are to the verses and Rashi's commentary, unless otherwise stated
![]() Mystery Contents | Solution to Sherlox Holmes"The beka and ten sela weights are completely ordinary for a ring and bracelets. There's nothing unusual about them at all," said Sherlox. "So," said Watstein. "So, why does the verse bother mentioning them?" "I see," said Watstein. "The verse could simply have said that Eliezer gave Rivka a gold ring and gold bracelets. These are common enough objects, such that we don't need to be told their exact weight - unless it's unusually big or small. But, as you pointed out, Mr. Holmes, there's nothing outstanding about a beka ring or two bracelets of ten sela. Hence, Rashi cites a midrash to explain why these seemingly ordinary weights are extra ordinary." "Extraordinary, Dr. Watstein. Now, please show that man in...."
(Source: Sifsei Chachamim; Sherlox" is by Reuven Subar,
inspired by Dr. Avigdor Bonchek's "What's Bothering Rashi") |
|---|
The Jewish Learning Exchange (JLE) of Ohr Somayach offers summer and winter programs in Israel that attract hundreds of university students from around the world for 3 to 8 weeks of study and touring.